Can IBC Be Used to Recover Unpaid Invoices? Why It Is Not Simply a Debt-Recovery Tool

An unpaid invoice can amount to an “operational debt” under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC), but that does not make the IBC an ordinary recovery mechanism. A Section 9 application is intended to commence corporate insolvency resolution where the statutory conditions are satisfied—not merely to pressure a customer into paying a disputed invoice.
For a business considering IBC over unpaid invoices, three questions are critical: Is the default at least ₹1 crore? Is the debt legally due and within limitation? And was there a genuine dispute before the Section 8 demand notice was received?
Why is IBC not simply a debt-recovery law?
The Supreme Court has made the purpose of the IBC clear.
In Swiss Ribbons Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India, (2019) 4 SCC 17, decided on 25 January 2019, the Supreme Court explained that the primary focus of the Code is the revival and continuation of the corporate debtor and that the IBC is not merely recovery legislation for creditors.
This distinction matters commercially.
A civil or commercial recovery proceeding principally asks:
Does A owe money to B, and if so, how much?
A Section 9 IBC proceeding asks a fundamentally different question:
Have the statutory conditions been met for commencing a corporate insolvency resolution process against the debtor?
Admission of a Section 9 petition can therefore have consequences far beyond the particular invoice. The Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) commences from the date of admission.
Can an unpaid invoice qualify as an operational debt?
Yes. Amounts payable for goods or services can ordinarily fall within the definition of an “operational debt” under Section 5(21) of the IBC, subject to the facts and contractual relationship.
The supplier claiming that debt is generally an operational creditor for IBC purposes.
But establishing an operational debt is only the starting point. A creditor must still satisfy Sections 4, 8 and 9 of the Code before CIRP can be initiated.
What is the minimum amount required for a Section 9 IBC case?
For corporate insolvency proceedings under Part II of the IBC, the current minimum amount of default is ₹1 crore.
Section 4 originally permitted a lower threshold, but the Central Government, through Notification S.O. 1205(E) dated 24 March 2020, specified ₹1 crore as the minimum amount of default. The current statutory text continues to reflect that threshold.
Therefore, a supplier cannot ordinarily initiate CIRP under Section 9 merely because, for example, an invoice of ₹8 lakh or ₹40 lakh remains unpaid.
That does not mean the debt is unrecoverable. It means IBC is not the appropriate statutory route on that amount alone.
What must an operational creditor do before filing under Section 9?
Section 8 requires an operational creditor first to deliver a demand notice of the unpaid operational debt or a copy of the invoice demanding payment to the corporate debtor.
The debtor then has 10 days from receipt to bring to the creditor’s notice:
- the existence of a dispute relating to the debt; or
- evidence that the operational debt has been paid.
If payment is not received and there is no qualifying notice of dispute, the operational creditor may, after expiry of the 10-day period, file a Section 9 application before the NCLT.
The application is made in the prescribed form with supporting documents. The statutory filing fee prescribed for a Section 9 application is ₹2,000; professional and incidental costs are separate.
What happens if the buyer disputes the invoice?
A genuine pre-existing dispute can prevent admission of a Section 9 application.
This is one of the most important differences between insolvency proceedings and an ordinary money-recovery action.
In Mobilox Innovations Pvt. Ltd. v. Kirusa Software Pvt. Ltd., (2018) 1 SCC 353, decided on 21 September 2017, the Supreme Court held that the NCLT must consider whether a real dispute existed before receipt of the Section 8 demand notice. The Tribunal is not supposed to conduct a full trial of that dispute. It must determine whether there is a plausible contention requiring further investigation rather than a defence that is merely spurious, hypothetical or illusory.
Example
Assume a software supplier raises invoices worth ₹1.4 crore.
Before any IBC notice is issued, the customer has repeatedly written that:
- contractual milestones were missed;
- the software failed acceptance testing; and
- it has suffered losses and disputes the amount payable.
The supplier may ultimately prove in arbitration or a commercial suit that ₹1.4 crore is due.
But the existence of that genuine prior dispute may nevertheless prevent the supplier from using Section 9 to resolve the controversy.
IBC is not designed to conduct a detailed trial over whether the software performed according to contract.
Can a debtor manufacture a dispute after receiving the IBC notice?
A bare denial made only after receiving the Section 8 notice does not automatically defeat the creditor.
The critical question under Mobilox is whether a real dispute existed before the demand notice and whether the debtor’s contention has genuine substance.
NCLT is expected to distinguish a legitimate dispute from a sham defence. However, the Tribunal does not decide at the admission stage whether the debtor will ultimately win that dispute.
For creditors, this makes the documentary history extremely important. Purchase orders, emails, quality complaints, debit notes, acceptance certificates and earlier correspondence can materially affect whether Section 9 is maintainable.
What if an arbitral award exists but the customer has challenged it?
IBC may still be inappropriate where the underlying operational liability remains genuinely disputed.
In K. Kishan v. Vijay Nirman Company Pvt. Ltd., (2018) 17 SCC 662, the Supreme Court dealt with an operational debt embodied in an arbitral award that had been challenged under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act.
The Court emphasised that operational creditors cannot use the IBC prematurely or as a substitute for ordinary debt-enforcement procedures where a real dispute continues to exist.
The practical lesson is important: obtaining an invoice, acknowledgment or even an arbitral award does not automatically convert every contested commercial claim into an appropriate insolvency case.
Is there a limitation period for filing a Section 9 application?
Yes.
Section 238A of the IBC applies the Limitation Act, 1963 to IBC proceedings.
In B.K. Educational Services Pvt. Ltd. v. Parag Gupta & Associates, (2019) 11 SCC 633, decided on 11 October 2018, the Supreme Court held that Article 137 of the Limitation Act ordinarily applies to applications under Sections 7 and 9.
The general limitation period is therefore three years from when the right to apply accrues—ordinarily the date of default, subject to applicable provisions of the Limitation Act, including legally effective acknowledgment, exclusion or condonation principles where available.
Businesses should therefore avoid assuming that repeated reminders automatically preserve an old IBC claim.
When should a business consider Section 9 for unpaid invoices?
Section 9 is potentially appropriate where, among other things:
| Question | What the creditor should check |
| Is the debtor a corporate person covered by Part II of the IBC? | Confirm the legal entity against which CIRP is proposed |
| Is there an operational debt? | Verify the contractual basis for goods or services supplied |
| Is the default at least ₹1 crore? | Section 4 threshold must be satisfied |
| Is the debt due and unpaid? | Check invoices, due dates and payments |
| Is it within limitation? | Usually examine the three-year period from default and any legally relevant acknowledgment |
| Was there a dispute before the Section 8 notice? | Review emails, complaints, debit notes, arbitration and litigation |
| Has a proper Section 8 notice been served? | Procedural compliance is essential |
| Is insolvency genuinely appropriate? | Do not treat CIRP merely as collection pressure |
This is a screening checklist, not a substitute for reviewing the specific transaction.
What alternatives are available if IBC is not appropriate?
An unpaid invoice can remain legally recoverable even where Section 9 is unavailable.
Depending on the contract and the creditor’s status, alternatives can include:
1. Commercial suit
A supplier may institute a money-recovery or commercial suit where jurisdiction and the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 apply.
Where a commercial suit does not contemplate urgent interim relief, Section 12A generally requires pre-institution mediation. The Supreme Court confirmed the mandatory nature of that requirement in Patil Automation Pvt. Ltd. v. Rakheja Engineers Pvt. Ltd., (2022) 10 SCC 1.
2. Arbitration
Where the contract contains a valid arbitration agreement, the dispute may need to be resolved through arbitration rather than insolvency proceedings.
3. MSME Facilitation Council
Eligible micro or small enterprises may have a particularly important remedy under the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006.
Section 15 regulates the period for payment, while Section 16 provides for compound interest with monthly rests at three times the RBI-notified bank rate where payment is delayed. Section 18 provides the mechanism for reference to the Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council.
Whether this remedy is available must be examined against the supplier’s MSME status and the facts of the transaction.
What is the biggest mistake businesses make when using IBC for invoices?
The biggest mistake is treating a Section 8 notice as an enhanced legal demand letter.
The real question is not simply:
“Has the customer failed to pay?”
It is:
“Does this unpaid operational debt satisfy the statutory conditions for placing the corporate debtor into the insolvency-resolution framework?”
That distinction explains why IBC can be extremely effective in the right case but inappropriate in a genuine contractual dispute.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Can I file an IBC case for a ₹25 lakh unpaid invoice?
Ordinarily no. The current minimum default threshold for Part II corporate insolvency proceedings is ₹1 crore.
2. Can several invoices be considered together?
Potentially, depending on whether they constitute legally due operational debt and satisfy the statutory requirements. The transaction history and dates of default should be examined carefully.
3. Does sending a Section 8 notice guarantee admission by the NCLT?
No. Notice is only a statutory preliminary step. The NCLT must still consider the requirements of Section 9.
4. Can a customer defeat IBC simply by denying liability?
Not merely by making an unsupported denial. Under Mobilox, the dispute must be genuine rather than spurious, hypothetical or illusory.
5. Does the dispute need to be in court before the Section 8 notice?
No. Mobilox makes clear that a genuine pre-existing dispute need not already have resulted in a pending lawsuit or arbitration.
6. How much time does the debtor have after receiving a Section 8 notice?
Section 8 gives the corporate debtor 10 days from receipt to bring payment or the existence of a dispute to the operational creditor’s notice.
7. How quickly must NCLT decide a Section 9 application?
Section 9(5) states that the Adjudicating Authority shall admit or reject the application within 14 days of receipt, subject to the statutory requirements. Actual case progression can depend on procedural and judicial factors.
8. Can I use both IBC and arbitration?
The existence of an arbitration clause alone does not necessarily bar IBC. But a genuine pre-existing dispute, including an existing arbitral dispute in appropriate circumstances, can make Section 9 unavailable.
9. Is IBC better than filing a recovery suit?
Not automatically. IBC serves an insolvency-resolution purpose. A recovery suit, arbitration or MSME remedy may be more appropriate where the main objective is adjudication and recovery of a disputed contractual amount.
2 Responses